casamova

Composite vs timber decking: which is right for you?

Timber looks natural and feels warm underfoot. Composite’s less fuss but a different look. Here’s how the two stack up on looks, care, grip and lifespan, and what really keeps a deck going.

A good deck makes use of awkward corners and brings a bit of order to the garden. Choosing your boards is what matters most. Composite vs timber decking comes up again and again. No single answer. Both work, if you know what you're getting.

Timber: natural, warm and repairable

Timber looks and feels like what it is: wood. Softwood is the budget choice, treated to resist rot. Hardwood costs more and lasts longer with real character. Timber can be sanded, stained and repaired board by board.

Where the wood comes from matters too. Ask for timber from responsibly managed forests, and check that softwood has been properly pressure treated for ground contact where it's needed in the frame.

The catch is upkeep. Timber wants cleaning and treating every year or two, and left alone it greys, can split and may grow slippery in shade.

Composite: low upkeep, consistent looks

Composite decking's a mix of wood fibres and plastic. It doesn’t rot, warp or splinter, and you won’t be oiling it every year. Most times, just a quick wash brings it up like new. Go for the better brands and you’ll get a board with a good grain and colour that holds up outdoors.

Boards clip together from the side, so you get a clean top with no visible screws. It’s neater, but it does add a bit to the bill and takes longer to fit. On balance, worth it if you want that sharp finish.

Fascia boards matter. They cover the cut ends and hide the frame below, but are often missed off quotes. We always ask for them. Tidies up the job and makes the edge look finished, not raw.

It costs more up front. On really hot days, composite gets warmer underfoot than timber. Cheaper boards can look a bit plastic and flat, especially after a year or two. Ask to see whole boards outdoors, not just a shop sample. Ideally, check them in the sun and the rain.

Colour's one to watch. Dark boards look smart but show every scuff and heat up fast. Paler shades stay cooler and hide the dirt. You don't notice every mark.

Composite vs timber decking side by side

  • Looks: Timber’s never the same twice. Boards show grain, knots, the odd streak or dent, no hiding what it is. Composite’s uniform. Every length matches, straight from the mould.
  • Upkeep: Timber wants looking after, oil or stain every couple of years, without fail. Composite’s simpler. Bit of a wash down, scrub off the green. Leave either one to it and algae or muck will settle, especially where water sits.
  • Grip: Both can go slippery. Shade, fallen leaves, a persistent drip, all make a difference. Grooves and textured surfaces help, but don’t rely on the blurb.
  • Life: Both can last, as long as the joists and frame aren’t left to rot. We see most problems start underneath, where damp hangs about and dirt piles up.
  • Cost: Timber starts out cheaper. But add up the tins of oil, the time, swapping planks that don’t make it, and composite can come out better value once a few years have passed.

People notice the boards, but it's always the frame that fails first. That's what decides if a deck lasts five years or twenty.

What makes any deck last

It’s the subframe that carries the load, though most people hardly give it a thought. Needs to be proper treated timber or aluminium, with joists spaced to suit the deck boards you’ve chosen. The footings have to be steady, and the fixings up to the job. Leave out any of these and you’ll spot boards that bounce, twist or worse, rot creeping up from below.

Wooden fence with garden: highlights importance of sturdy subframe for decking

On a slope, the frame’s got even more work to do. Posts should go on real concrete footings, set deep enough to hold steady, so the whole thing stays level year after year. Drop posts straight into earth and you’re likely to see sagging once the ground gets soaked or dries right out.

Water needs somewhere to go. If it sits under the deck, the frame never dries. Worse still if there’s no air flow. We lay down a weed membrane and cover with gravel, so water drains off and weeds keep out.

Mixing decking with paving

Most gardens work better when you mix deck and paving. Paving up by the house gives you a firm spot for the dining table and barbecue, then the deck sits further out to catch whatever sun there is later on. If you've got a slope, a deck saves you shifting tonnes of hardcore or building heavy retaining walls for paving. Everything looks more settled when you plan both surfaces together, not bolt one on years after the other.

Elegant townhouse facade with symmetrical windows and a black door at sunset

Lighting shifts the whole space. We're fans of small LED lights sunk into the steps or edging boards. You’ll use the deck well into the night, and it stops anyone going flying. Run your cables in before you screw down the boards, or you’ll regret it.

Choosing who builds it

  • Ask to see decks they built several years ago, not just new ones.
  • Check what the frame will be made of and how it's fixed.
  • Ask how drainage and airflow underneath are handled.
  • Confirm the board maker's fitting rules are followed, or the warranty may not apply.
Front garden with gravel path and plants: consider professional help for deck building

Looking after your deck

Timber needs a good scrub and a fresh coat of oil or stain most years. Best done on a dry weekend in spring, once the boards have dried right through. Composite’s less hassle. Warm soapy water and a soft brush is enough.

Classic home with manicured garden: regular maintenance keeps timber decking pristine

Skip the pressure washer. Too easy to rough up timber or leave streaks on composite. We use a stiff brush and some effort. Shifts most of what ends up on a deck.

Letting leaves build up is asking for trouble. Clear out the gaps so rain can run off. Got a loose screw or a step that moves? Worth checking everything each spring and tightening what needs it.

Decks left shaded go slippery once algae gets a foothold. Happens a lot. A solid clean in autumn, then again in spring, keeps it down.

Our view

If you like the idea of your deck turning silvery and don’t mind scrubbing or re-oiling it now and then, timber’s the way. Composite suits anyone who’d rather skip the upkeep and just hose it down. The real secret? It’s not the boards, it’s the subframe. Get those joists properly fixed and leave a gap underneath, so the deck can breathe. That stops rot taking hold.

Find landscaping & gardens firms on casamova

Questions people ask

Does composite decking get hot?

Composite can get quite hot in strong sun, often hotter than timber—especially dark boards. If you don’t want burnt feet, go for lighter colours or pick a spot that gets some shade.

Is composite decking slippery?

A good composite board’s got a grain you can feel, and that helps. But any deck will go slippery if it’s left to gather muck or algae, particularly in a damp corner. We see it all the time.

How long does timber decking last?

Treated timber decking, on a solid frame, keeps going for years—doesn’t matter if it’s softwood or hardwood. Miss the regular oiling or let the frame rot and it won’t last.

Do I need planning permission for decking?

You usually don’t need planning for a ground-level deck, but if it’s raised or close to a boundary, that can change. Best to check with your council before getting stuck in.

Filed under Landscaping & Gardens, Decking & Outdoor Living Areas, Patios, Paving & Driveways, Landscape Construction

Ready to get quotes?

Say what you want in your own words. Up to 3 professionals quote.

Free for homeowners, no obligation.

Yours to keep. Download or print your request and every quote as a casamova PDF, and use them anywhere, with anyone.

Start a project

Get the next guide

One guide for your stage of the home, every two weeks.

Where is your home right now?

Your email is used only for these guides.

casamova editorial

casamova

Find a landscaping & gardens professional

Ordered by casamova Score. Nobody pays to appear here.

See professionals

Read all guides

casamovaProOur aim: a working day a week, back.

A business that runs
without you.

You master your trade. We master the technology. Live in a day, results from day one, a big difference by day 90.

  • Time freedom
  • Financial freedom
  • Location freedom
Show me howFive founding places per trade in each area.