casamova

Flat roof options: felt, rubber, fibreglass or liquid?

Flat roofs get a bad press, but it's not always fair. Felt, rubber, fibreglass or liquid, each has its place. The best option depends on your roof, your budget and who's actually doing the work.

Flat roofs. People hear that and think of a cracked old garage, water dripping into a bucket. Fair. Most of the blame goes to thin felt, bodged on a Friday. The truth is, flat roof options have moved on. Done properly, some go for decades without trouble.

The four main flat roof options

Felt roofs have changed a lot. These days, the roofer torches it on or sticks it down cold, always layering it properly. The old stuff was thin and tore at the joins, never lasted. Modern felt, if it goes down right, stands up well against wind and rain. Joins still let water creep in when someone rushes. We come across plenty like that. If you want something basic that won’t break the bank, felt still does the job. It’s plain, nothing flashy. It just sits there and keeps the weather out.

Green roofs are another story. They go on top of a waterproof base, usually you’ll see sedum, sometimes wildflowers or rough grass. Most people don’t expect the weight. You need proper joists underneath or the whole lot sags. The planting isn’t set-and-forget, either. You’ll need to get up there, clear out weeds, make sure the drains aren’t blocked. But looking down on greenery rather than felt is a nicer view, and it slows the rain so less rushes into the gutter all at once. Birds and insects seem to like it too.

Everything starts with the old deck. Rot in the timbers or a sagging board under the felt and no fancy roof will save it. Too many jobs skip this. A careful roofer strips it right back, checks every board, then builds up again. Not a stage to gloss over.

EPDM rubber’s everywhere now. It rolls out in one big sheet, glued down with barely any joins, less to let water through. The stuff flexes with the weather, so it’s good for extensions and garages where things might shift. You see a lot of it these days.

Fibreglass (GRP) goes further. It’s laid as resin and mat, then sets solid, all in one. No seams, just a flat, tough finish. Works well for awkward shapes or upstands, and you can walk on it without much worry. Sun doesn’t bother it, either.

Liquid coatings get brushed or rolled on, forming a single watertight skin as they cure. Handy for odd shapes, pipes or patching round rooflights. Sometimes you can go straight over what’s already there, no need to strip everything back.

What decides the right choice

  • The size and shape of the roof.
  • Whether people will walk on it, or it becomes a terrace.
  • Details such as rooflights, vents and walls it meets.
  • Whether the deck underneath is sound.
  • Which material the installer really knows well.

That last one matters more than any brochure. A fibreglass roof by someone who does them every week beats a rubber roof by someone trying it for the first time.

Roofers using torches to install felt: ensure contractors have relevant expertise

Insulation and condensation

Replacing a flat roof covering is a good moment to add insulation. Warm roofs, with insulation above the deck, keep the structure warm and reduce condensation risk. Ask whether building regulations apply; they often do when a roof is replaced.

Cold roofs, with insulation between the joists below the deck, can work too but need careful ventilation to stop condensation forming inside. Your roofer or building control officer can tell you which suits your roof.

Water always wins eventually. A flat roof's job is to make sure it takes a very long time.

Drainage: the part people forget

Flat roofs aren’t truly flat. There’s always a slight slope, just enough to send rain towards the gutters or downpipes. If water sits around for days, it finds its way into tiny cracks and seams. That’s when leaks start. We’d insist on a proper fall, with no dips, and make sure outlets are actually big enough for a downpour.

Team fitting gutters on a sloped roof: proper drainage prevents water damage

If you’re building out, take a look from the upstairs window. Flat roofs are hard to ignore from above. You’ll notice scruffy details every day. It’s worth asking for tidy edges, or consider a layer of gravel or planting if you want something softer to look at.

Leaves, twigs, moss, it all ends up in flat roof gutters. Outlets block easily. One heavy shower and suddenly you’ve got a pond up there. We see this all the time. A quick clear-out each autumn usually keeps everything flowing.

Rooflights and other details

Rooflights change a room. More daylight, a sense of space, makes all the difference in an extension. But every rooflight means more edges, more joins, and more places where water could sneak in. You want well-made units with a decent U-value, and you want them built in from the start. Fitted with the roof, not bodged in after.

Consider where the sunlight will hit. Over a kitchen island or table, it’s spot on. Over your TV or bed, less so, can feel harsh. Rooflight blinds aren’t just for show. They make hot days bearable.

Looking after a flat roof

  • Clear leaves and moss from outlets and gutters each autumn.
  • Look for blisters, cracks or pooling after winter.
  • Check where the roof meets walls and rooflights.
  • Fix small issues quickly, before water gets underneath.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • What material are you quoting for, and how many of these roofs do you actually fit each year?
  • Will you check under the old covering and sort the boards if they're rotten?
  • How will you get the water off, what’s the plan for the slope and the outlets?
  • Are you including insulation, and will this job need building control sign-off?
  • What guarantee do I get, both for the material and your work?
Roofers using torches to install felt: ensure contractors have relevant expertise

Get it all down on paper. A proper quote is what stands between you and trouble later.

Our view

Flat roofs last when the slope’s right, the water goes where it should and the person fitting it knows what they’re about. We’d always choose the installer first, then let them work with the material they trust most. And while the roof’s open, put in more insulation. No better time.

Find roofing & exteriors firms on casamova

Antonio Ferreira

Reviewed by

Antonio Ferreira

Founder of casamova

Technology visionary and disruptive innovation expert with nearly 30 years of experience shaping the future of technology, automotive, mobility and smart cities. Former Technology Innovation Leader at NEOM, entrepreneur, strategic advisor and investor in emerging technologies and disruptive start-ups.

Follow on LinkedIn
Antonio Ferreira signatureAntonio FerreiraFounder of casamova

Questions people ask

How long does a flat roof last?

If it's done properly, a flat roof should last decades. But it depends on what you cover it with, whether the water actually runs off, how much you walk on it and if you keep the gutters clear of leaves and debris.

Is EPDM rubber better than fibreglass?

There's no clear winner. EPDM rubber suits simple shapes, since you can usually lay it with hardly any joins. Fibreglass is tougher if you need to walk on it or the roof has odd angles, but the boards underneath must be perfectly flat.

Can I put a terrace on a flat roof?

You can, but only if the structure below will take the weight. The joists need to be solid, the surface walkable, and the railings secure. You’ll almost always need planning permission as well.

Why is water pooling on my flat roof?

If water's pooling, chances are the roof doesn't slope enough, the decking has dipped or the drain's blocked. Any decent roofer will spot the cause and tell you what needs doing.

Filed under Roofing & Exteriors, Flat Roofing, Roof Waterproofing, Skylights & Roof Windows

Ready to get quotes?

Say what you want in your own words. Up to 3 professionals quote.

Free for homeowners, no obligation.

Yours to keep. Download or print your request and every quote as a casamova PDF, and use them anywhere, with anyone.

Start a project

Get the next guide

One guide for your stage of the home, every two weeks.

Where is your home right now?

Your email is used only for these guides.

casamova editorial

casamova

Find a roofing & exteriors professional

Ordered by casamova Score. Nobody pays to appear here.

See professionals

Read all guides

casamovaProOur aim: a working day a week, back.

A business that runs
without you.

You master your trade. We master the technology. Live in a day, results from day one, a big difference by day 90.

  • Time freedom
  • Financial freedom
  • Location freedom
Show me howFive founding places per trade in each area.