casamova

When to replace your boiler, and how to choose the next one

Boilers rarely give much warning before they give up. Catch problems early, pick your next one carefully, and don’t let anyone overcharge for installation.

Boilers don’t tend to fail quietly. They often wait for the coldest Monday morning, just as you’re counting on hot water. If yours is getting on and playing up, don’t leave it to chance. Change it before you’re stuck with no heating and an icy bath.

Signs it's time to replace your boiler

  • It breaks down once or twice every winter.
  • Your engineer can’t get hold of parts without a hunt.
  • Bills have crept up, though you haven’t changed how you use it.
  • Radiators take forever to get warm, or hot water turns tepid halfway through.
  • Your engineer mentions anything about safety.

One on its own doesn’t mean you must act. But get two or three, and it’s probably time. Any mention of safety, especially risk of carbon monoxide, means you don’t wait. You act now.

Just being old isn’t a reason if it still runs well and passes service checks. Still, old boilers waste more gas and spare parts dry up. Better to plan than to get caught without heating in the middle of winter.

Combi, system or regular

Combi boilers heat water as you use it. No cylinder, no tank in the loft. They work best in smaller places, one bathroom, where you won't have two showers going at once. System boilers fill a cylinder, so you've got hot water ready, better for bigger households and busy mornings. Regular boilers, with both a cylinder and tanks up in the loft, tend to crop up in older houses. We see them most in places that've barely changed since the eighties.

Technicians installing a heating system: choose between combi, system, or regular boilers

Think about where the boiler sits. If it's in a bedroom cupboard or somewhere awkward, now's the time to get it moved, maybe to the loft or a utility room. It costs more, but if you're replacing your boiler anyway, it can be a good moment to sort it. Talk it through properly with your engineer before deciding.

Sticking with the same type is usually the least hassle. Changing to a different kind often means a lot more pipework and disruption. If your installer says you need a different type, ask them to spell out exactly why. We always would.

Getting the size right

Bigger isn’t better. Fit a boiler that’s too big and it’ll keep cutting in and out, burning more gas than it should, wearing parts early and costing you. Sizing comes down to what your house actually needs. For a combi, you also need to think about how much hot water you want from your kitchen and bathroom taps. The best engineers don’t guess. They check the numbers.

Engineers working on an outdoor unit: ensure the right boiler size for efficiency

Controls make a bigger difference than people think

Smart thermostats, room-by-room radiator valves and weather compensation, where the boiler adjusts to the outside temperature, can make a home feel more comfortable and cost less to heat. They're worth discussing even if you keep things simple.

Room-by-room control is especially useful in homes where some rooms are rarely used. Heating the spare bedroom to the same temperature as the living room every day is money quietly going up the chimney.

A good boiler with poor controls is a sports car stuck in first gear.

If you're replacing a boiler anyway, it's worth at least asking whether a heat pump would suit your home. It doesn't for everyone. But knowing the answer before you sign for another fifteen years of gas is sensible.

Comparing quotes fairly

  • Is it the same boiler model and size on each quote?
  • Are the controls, filter and system flush included?
  • How long is the warranty, and what does it need to stay valid?
  • Will the installation be registered and certified?
  • Who do you call if it goes wrong in year three?

The cheapest quote often leaves out the system flush or the filter, which protect the new boiler. Check the detail.

Technicians checking connections: compare quotes to include essential system protection

Ask too how long the job will take and whether you'll have heating and hot water overnight. A clear plan for the day, and a tidy finish where the old boiler came off the wall, are signs of an installer who takes care.

Radiators and the rest of the system

New boiler, same old radiators and mucky pipes? You'll soon notice. Sludge in the system drags everything down, leaving rooms half-warm or the rads cold at the bottom. We’d always sort a power flush or chemical clean, fit a magnetic filter and bleed every radiator before calling a job finished. Otherwise, you’re wasting your money on the boiler.

Looking after the new one

Book a boiler service every year. It keeps things running how they should, helps your boiler last, and you keep the warranty. The engineer looks for leaks, checks it’s burning safely, clears out the grime and often spots trouble before it leaves you without heating.

Engineer inspects outdoor boiler unit: regular checks prevent unexpected heating issues

Some manufacturers stretch the warranty if you use one of their approved installers. Worth asking, but always check the small print. Miss even one service and you’ll likely find the guarantee’s not worth much.

Keep an eye on the pressure gauge in between visits. If your radiators are cold at the top, bleed them. If you start hearing banging or any odd noises, kettling, as engineers call it, don’t just ignore it. That’s your cue something’s wrong.

Spend ten minutes learning the new controls. Set a proper schedule, tweak the room temperatures. It’s the bit most people rush, but getting it right makes a bigger difference than you might think.

Our view

Leaving it till the boiler fails, bad idea. If yours is limping along, get moving. Proper quotes, all in writing, no assumptions about what's included. Fitting, flushing, controls, it all matters. Don't cut corners on the controls or skip a good flush through the pipes. You'll notice it in your bills and how long the new boiler lasts.

Find heating, cooling & hvac firms on casamova

Antonio Ferreira

Reviewed by

Antonio Ferreira

Founder of casamova

Technology visionary and disruptive innovation expert with nearly 30 years of experience shaping the future of technology, automotive, mobility and smart cities. Former Technology Innovation Leader at NEOM, entrepreneur, strategic advisor and investor in emerging technologies and disruptive start-ups.

Follow on LinkedIn
Antonio Ferreira signatureAntonio FerreiraFounder of casamova

Questions people ask

How long does a boiler last?

Most boilers will do ten years if you keep up with the yearly servicing. Once breakdowns start or spares get tricky, it’s time to replace your boiler.

Is a combi boiler right for my home?

A combi works for a flat or a small house, so long as you’re not all trying to shower at once. If there’s more than one bathroom or a busy household, a system boiler with a hot water cylinder takes the strain.

How long does a boiler replacement take?

A straight swap can be wrapped up in a day, two if the old pipes have other ideas. Switching to a different type or moving it to a new spot always takes longer.

What keeps a boiler warranty valid?

You’ll need to register the warranty as soon as the new boiler goes in, and book a service every year with a qualified engineer. Some brands tuck in extra small print, so it’s worth reading through the lot.

Filed under Heating, Cooling & HVAC, Boiler Installation & Repair, Central Heating Systems, Air Conditioning Servicing & Repair

Ready to get quotes?

Say what you want in your own words. Up to 3 professionals quote.

Free for homeowners, no obligation.

Yours to keep. Download or print your request and every quote as a casamova PDF, and use them anywhere, with anyone.

Start a project

Get the next guide

One guide for your stage of the home, every two weeks.

Where is your home right now?

Your email is used only for these guides.

casamova editorial

casamova

Find a heating, cooling & HVAC professional

Ordered by casamova Score. Nobody pays to appear here.

See professionals

Read all guides

casamovaProOur aim: a working day a week, back.

A business that runs
without you.

You master your trade. We master the technology. Live in a day, results from day one, a big difference by day 90.

  • Time freedom
  • Financial freedom
  • Location freedom
Show me howFive founding places per trade in each area.